The Impact of ACO Consolidation on Medicare Prices and Quality of Care

by | Aug 8, 2024

The Impact of ACO Consolidation on Medicare Prices and Quality of Care

Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) have changed the healthcare landscape for Medicare beneficiaries. ACOs aim to deliver high-quality, coordinated care; however, as these physician practices and hospitals consolidate, concerns about rising Medicare prices and the impact on the quality of care they provide are unproven. Let’s discuss how this impacts the future of Medicare.

Evidence of Higher Medicare Prices

Several studies have shown that ACO consolidation can lead to higher Medicare prices. When physicians and hospitals consolidate into ACOs, their market power increases. This allows them to negotiate higher service prices with Medicare. Independent physician practices join health system-led ACOs and jointly negotiate prices that can lead to significant increases for Medicare  (Center for American Progress). For example, a study published in Health Affairs found that independent physician practices within system-led ACOs experienced an average price increase of 49.3% after joining the ACO  (RevCycleIntelligence). Additionally, evidence from the Center for American Progress indicates that consolidation has consistently led to higher healthcare prices, with hospital mergers and acquisitions driving up costs significantly  (Center for American Progress).

Evidence of Quality of Care

The impact of ACO consolidation on the quality of care is unclear and remains a subject of ongoing debate. While the potential for improved care coordination and resource sharing exists, the evidence of actual quality improvements needs clarification. Some studies suggest that larger ACOs may have the leverage to reduce hospital readmissions and manage chronic diseases more effectively.

Consolidating Healthcare Provider Markets in Medicare

Regulators must monitor ACO consolidations to ensure that the mergers do not stifle competition and are essential for maintaining affordable healthcare. Supporting smaller ACOs can also encourage competition and innovation.

The consolidation of Accountable Care Organizations brings opportunities and challenges to the Medicare system. While larger ACOs can potentially improve care coordination and patient outcomes, the evidence indicates that such consolidations can also lead to higher Medicare prices. Balancing these outcomes requires careful regulatory oversight and support for smaller providers to ensure that the benefits of consolidation are realized without compromising affordability or care quality.

By addressing these key considerations, we can navigate the complexities of ACO consolidation to create a Medicare system that delivers both high-quality care and value to its beneficiaries.

About Dayna Schafer

Dayna is a Certified Medicare Insurance Planner™, a member of the Rise Community, and founding member at Bayside Health Benefits. Her agency is located in Homosassa, FL, and concentrates throughout Florida, where she guides Medicare beneficiaries in navigating the complexities of Medicare insurance options. In addition to certifying with 10 insurers, Dayna focuses on the quality and integrity that comes with relentlessly seeking the right fit for her client’s healthcare needs.

Get Help Today

Are you new to Medicare? Considering you’re Medicare Options?

Join our Webinar to explore eligibility, enrollment timelines, 3 Medicare options, and penalties.

Mondays at 11:30AM

To speak with a licensed agent call 727-375-2700 or